Yesterday afternoon, Jonathan Broxton notched his 18th save of the year (good for fourth in the American League) and with it secured a winning road trip for the Royals. He did so in what has become typical Broxton fashion, allowing two baserunners before finally getting his team out of the inning.
So far in 2012, Broxton has had 21 save opportunities and blown (generally in spectacular fashion) three of them. Obviously, in those three, Jonathan allowed baserunners. In the 18 successful saves, Broxton has retired the side in order just five times. Broxton has had some other perfect innings, but in non-save situations.
In the remaining 13 saves, Broxton has allowed just one baserunner six times, two baserunners six more times and loaded the bases once. Is that normal?
In 2008, we saw Joakim Soria in this prime just dominate. He went seven straight appearances without allowing any baserunners and had another stretch where he did not allow a baserunner in eight out of nine appearances. Soria blew three saves that entire season. In 2006, division rival Joe Nathan blew two saves all season and in 21 of his 36 successful save conversions, threw perfect innings.
Those are two very good closers in probably their two best years, however. Where does Broxton stand right now? Is he getting just plain lucky and due for a series of devastating team gutting blown saves? Or is this how it is across baseball? Royals’ arch-enemy Chris Perez leads the league in saves, let’s take a look at what he has done.
Perez has converted 22 out of 23 save opportunities. He had a one out save, which we will sort out of the equation. Of the 21 remaining saves, Perez was perfect in 9 of those. He allowed one baserunner in 6, two baserunners in 5 and three baserunners in the other. It is noteworthy that while Broxton has not allowed a run in any of his 18 successful saves, Chris Perez has three times allowed a run to score, but had enough cushion to still get the save. In comparing Perez vs. Broxton, we see a few more flashes of dominance out of Perez, but also some poorer outings as well: not a tremendous difference, frankly.
The Orioles Jim Johnson is second in the league in saves and has allowed just 15 hits in 31 innings of work. Johnson has converted 20 of 21 save opportunities and been perfect in 9 of those 19 saves. He has allowed one baserunner eight times, two on three occassions and never has put three runners on base. Johnson has, however, allowed a run and still gotten the save twice. It is also noteworthy that in his last six save opportunites, Jim has blown one and been perfect the other five times.
The only other closer in the AL with more saves than Broxton is Tampa’s Fernando Rodney. Two of his twenty saves (the first two actually) were just one out saves and Rodney has blown one save opportunity as well. Of the remaining 18 saves, Rodney has been perfect in 12 of them. He allowed one baserunner in four (along with an unearned run), two baserunners just once and three baserunners once (along with a run).
I am going to skip down a couple of spots to the most established closer type on the leaderboard: Joe Nathan. The Rangers’ closer has converted 15 of 16 save opportunities and been perfect in 10 of those. In the other five saves, Nathan has allowed one baserunner four times and two runners just once. He has not allowed a run in a successful save situation.
Now, baserunners happen. Allowing one batter to reach base in the ninth inning is hardly a sign of the apocalypse (at least I don’t think so, the Mayans are hard to figure out), so let’s forgive all those outings for the guys we are looking at and compare the number of multiple runners on in save situations:
- Perez – 6 out of 21 (1 blown save)
- Johnson – 3 out of 20 (1 blown save)
- Rodney – 2 out of 18 (1 blown save)
- Broxton – 7 out of 18 (3 blown saves)
- Nathan – 1 out of 15 (1 blown save)
Quick and dirty research tells us that Broxton’s success, if not lucky, has come in a manner different than that of the other save leaders in the league. That said, closers are all different (I mean, most of them are really, really different) maybe Broxton has always been this way.
Well, in 2009, Broxton had a career high 36 saves, striking out 114 in 76 innings. He allowed more than one baserunner in just 7 of those 36 successful saves, but he also suffered six blown saves. In 2010, he was 22 of 27 in save opportunities and allowed multiple baserunners in five of his 22 successful saves. It is noteworthy that his 2010 performance resulted in Broxton losing his closer job in August.
In his prime, Broxton did not walk the high wire to quite the extent he has thus far for the Royals (although he was still prone to the blown save). That does not mean that Jonathan will not be able to continue: the ability to throw 98 mph can help offset runners on base. However, the odds would seem to suggest that Broxton might be running out of wiggle room.
There is, however, one additional consideration. Broxton is really just two and one-half months back from injury. He has spent the better part of the last two years getting lit up. Could this all be just part of ‘getting back’? I think that is a very real possibility and the truth is, if Broxton ends up saving 36 games this year, blowing six and taking us on a ride in half of those 36 successes, that is still going to be a pretty decent year.
It’s not dominant and it’s not ideal, but not everyone can be Joakim Soria. Heck, Joakim Soria wasn’t Joakim Soria the last couple of years.